Mirror Image Mindset: Thinking Like a Cybercriminal, Hacker, Criminal, and Computer User

"Thinking like your adversary" is a cornerstone of effective investigations. But there is a common misconception: thinking like your adversary (aka: mirror image mindset) doesn’t mean becoming the person you’re investigating. It’s not an exact match but rather a reversed reflection. Just as a mirror flips left to right, thinking like your adversary means viewing their actions and decisions from an inverted, critical perspective.
Dec 27 / Brett Shavers
We used to call forensic bit-for-bit copies of data "mirror images," but this was inaccurate and imprecise. A forensic image isn’t a reflection; it’s a metadata-rich copy preserving all source drive data with forensic integrity.

The same principle applies to understanding your adversary. The mirror image mindset isn’t about replication but more about reversal. It’s about adopting a new vantage point to anticipate actions, uncover evidence, and solve problems, all while staying firmly rooted in your role as an investigator.

Let’s talk about how this applies to thinking like a cybercriminal, hacker, criminal, or everyday computer user.

The Reverse Perspective: Thinking Like a Cybercriminal
Cybercriminals can be highly organized, profit-driven, and calculated in their methods. Adopting a mirror image perspective means flipping their logic to understand and counteract their actions:

Anticipating Vulnerabilities: Cybercriminals exploit weaknesses. Your reverse perspective is to identify those same vulnerabilities first, considering how they might be leveraged.

Decoding Priorities: Cybercriminals focus on low-risk, high-reward opportunities. You can predict where they will strike next if you invert their logic.

Exposing Sloppiness: Criminals work hard to evade detection but often leave subtle traces in their rush. A reversed perspective helps you identify what they missed while focusing on their goals.

The Reverse Perspective: Thinking Like a Hacker
Hackers are often driven by curiosity, intellectual challenge, or a desire for recognition. The mirror image mindset here involves understanding their exploratory nature and reversing it:

Following Their Curiosity: Hackers leave breadcrumbs as they probe systems. You can trace their exploratory steps and identify entry points by reversing their logic.

Breaking Down Their Tools: Hackers often repurpose tools in unexpected ways. By mirroring this creativity, you can analyze their actions and anticipate their methods.

Predicting Next Moves: Hackers experiment constantly. Thinking in reverse helps you stay one step ahead by considering what you’d do next in their position.

The Reverse Perspective: Thinking Like a Criminal
Traditional criminals using technology are often less skilled in digital tactics but just as dangerous. The mirror image mindset helps you view their actions from an inverted angle:

Uncovering Simplicity: Many criminals rely on basic tools and methods. Reversing their simplicity lets you see where they might leave gaps in their tracks.

Tracing Familiar Habits: Criminals often stick to what they know. The mirror image mindset flips this familiarity into predictable patterns you can follow.

Reversing Their Focus: While they’re focused on achieving their objectives, your job is to uncover the evidence they didn’t think to hide.

The Reverse Perspective: Thinking Like a Computer User
Not all investigations involve malicious actors. Sometimes, the key to solving a case lies in understanding the routine behaviors of everyday computer users:

Flipping Habits Into Clues: Users often leave patterns in their digital activities. By reversing their habits, you can uncover evidence of their intent.

Spotting Mistakes: Regular users often leave inadvertent traces—cached files, autofill data, or forgotten backups. The mirror image approach flips these unintentional actions into deliberate investigative leads.

Reversing Emotional Decisions: Users often act on impulse or emotion. Your job is to analyze their actions logically, considering how haste or frustration left evidence behind.

The Ethics of the Mirror Image Mindset
Thinking like your adversary doesn’t mean becoming them. The mirror image is a reflection, not a replication. It allows you to reverse their actions and motivations without losing sight of your ethical responsibilities. By analyzing their behavior from an inverted perspective, you maintain your role as an investigator while outmaneuvering their efforts.

The mirror image mindset also ensures you stay grounded in your mission: uncovering the truth. It’s about seeing the problem from their perspective, flipping it, and finding solutions that reveal what they worked to conceal.
The last thing you want is for thinking like a criminal to cross the line into unethical behavior, blurring the boundaries between investigator and offender. Many Hollywood police movies are like this, where the detective breaks the law to catch the criminal. In real life, the investigator goes to jail, and the case is ruined.
Applying the Mirror Image Mindset

Here are practical ways to use the mirror image mindset effectively:

Reverse-Engineer Scenarios: Imagine yourself in their position, then work backward to uncover their actions.
Challenge Assumptions: Don’t take evidence at face value. Use the reversed perspective to question how and why traces were left behind.

Stay Ethical and Analytical: Remember that the mirror image is a tool for understanding, not justification or mimicry.

They use it, too
Your adversaries and suspects use this same tactic on you; thinking like their investigator to stay one step ahead. They anticipate the tools you’ll use, the methods you’ll apply, and the evidence you’ll look for, often tailoring their actions to evade detection or manipulate your investigation.

Just as we adopt a mirror-image mindset to understand their behavior, they reverse-engineer our processes, leveraging their knowledge of forensic techniques to cover their tracks, plant false leads, or exploit procedural gaps. This underscores the importance of thinking like them and beyond them—adapting quickly, staying unpredictable, and constantly evolving your investigative approach to counter their efforts.

Call to Action
Reversed logic is a powerful tool for DFIR professionals. It sharpens your investigative skills by helping you think critically and creatively about the actions of those on the other side of the keyboard. By stepping into this reversed perspective, you can uncover hidden evidence, anticipate future moves, and ultimately strengthen your ability to solve complex cases.

By embracing the mirror image mindset, we stay adaptable, ethical, and ready for any challenge your cases throw us.

Get in touch

  • admin@inv-network.org

About Us

Inv-Network was created to support those who are tasked with the difficult job of protecting children from online child exploitation. Our goal is to provide community, resources, and training to Law Enforcement, District Attorney's, and Parole & Probation Officers.
Copyright © 2023